SOCIAL DYNAMICS AND MARGINALIZED PERSPECTIVES DURING QING GOVERNANCE IN TAIWAN
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55197/qjssh.v6i4.673Keywords:
marginal character, homeland complex, migrant wave, border region, identityAbstract
The factors contributing to the unstable and “difficult-to-govern” society in Taiwan can be traced back to the period of the Ming dynasty (1368-1644). During this time, Guangdong and Fujian provinces ranked first and second in terms of social chaos, which accounted for 55% of incidents nationwide. Under the Qing dynasty's governance of Taiwan (1683-1895), officials showed little intention of governing effectively, resulting in poor administration, corruption, factionalism, and lax military discipline. This indirectly contributed to the reemergence of the hometown behavior patterns of Minnan Han immigrants in Taiwan. Several additional factors contribute to this instability: (1) The migration history has shaped the complex psychological state and cultural identity of the Han people from southern Fujian. Their “identity uncertainty” mentality has led to the reemergence of marginalized personalities and hometown behaviors, which in turn exacerbate social instability and other social issues in Taiwan. (2) The shifting political power during the Ming and Qing dynasties, particularly after 1644, triggered profound conflicts among the Han people in southern Fujian-especially among officials, intellectuals, and various social classes-regarding concepts of “loyalty,” “identity,” and “national identity.” A crisis of identity emerged concerning whether they belonged to the Ming or Qing dynasties. (3) The development of national sovereignty in Taiwan was incomplete. During the Qing dynasty's rule, the entire population of Taiwan was not fully integrated into the national system, resulting in many Han Chinese in Taiwan lacking a sense of belonging to the Qing dynasty and a unified national identity. The marginalized identities of the Han people from southern Fujian are not necessarily passive or disadvantaged. They have navigated dynastic changes throughout Chinese history and developed survival strategies that operate within the space between the center and the periphery. However, this marginalization can easily lead to the fragmentation of national identity.
References
[1] Andrade, T. (2008): How Taiwan became Chinese: Dutch, Spanish, and Han colonization in the seventeenth century. – New York: Columbia University Press 324p.
[2] Chen, M.S. (2010): The interaction of ethnic spirit and local consciousness among the Taiwanese people during the Ming-Zheng period. – Southeast Academic Research 8p.
[3] Chen, S.S. (2024): Wun Su Lu II. – Chinese Text Project 19p.
[4] Clements, J. (2004): Pirate king: Coxinga and the fall of the Ming dynasty. – Stroud, Gloucestershire: Sutton Press 16p.
[5] Common Wealth Magazine (1991): Open history, walk into the future, discover Taiwan 1620-1945. – Common Wealth Magazine 2p.
[6] Copper, J.F. (1990): Taiwan: Nation-state or province? – San Francisco: Westview Press 18p.
[7] Dai, G.Q. (2013): The female narratives of the “multifold marginal persons” --Novels created by the female writers of the new immigrants in the north America. – Jinan Journal (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 8p.
[8] Das, R.J. (1996): State theories: A critical analysis. – Science and Society 60(1): 27-57.
[9] Gao, H., Lu, R.H. (2002): Cultural identity and dilemmas in cultural clashes—Issues in overseas Chinese literature research through Lin Yutang. – Chinese Literature Studies 6p.
[10] Gellner, E. (2006): Nations and nationalism (2nd edition). – Cornell University Press 8p.
[11] Gilroy, P. (1993): The black altantic: Modernity and double consciousness. – Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 261p.
[12] Kerckhoff, A.C., McCormick, T.C. (1955): Marginal status and marginal personality. – Social Forces 34(1): 48-55.
[13] Lai, X.W. (2021): Historical talk the Qing dynasty’s Han population in Taiwan grew from 40,000 to 2.55 million-where did the Taiwanese come from (part 2). – China Times 3p.
[14] Lian, H. (2024): General history of Taiwan. – Chinese Text Project 5p.
[15] Lin, W.Y. (1995): From marginalization to autonomy in Taiwanese society. – Taiwan Professors Association Newsletter 2p.
[16] Lin, Z.H. (2005): Minyue? fukke? A new investigation of the han ethnic group relations in Qing Taiwan—Starting from the Pingtung plain. – National History Museum Academic Journal (6): 1-60.
[17] Mann, J.W. (1958): Group relations and the marginal personality. – Human Relations 11(1): 77-92.
[18] Poniatowska, E. (1996): Mexicanas and Chicanas. – MELUS 21(3): 35-51.
[19] Shi, L. (2024): Jing Hai Ji Shih Shang Jyuan. – Chinese Text Project 2p.
[20] Shi, Z.F. (2004): Taiwan Hakka ethnic politics and policies. – Taipei: Hanlu Press 93p.
[21] Stonequist, E.V. (1935): The problem of the marginal man. – The University of Chicago Press 41(1): 11-12.
[22] Sun, H. (2013): The lost self: Identity of edge character in “Miguel street”. – Journal of Yuzhang Normal University 2p.
[23] Tang, Y.J. (2019): The evolution of marginalized personalities in what is home? from the perspective of marginality theory. – Popular Literature and Art 2p.
[24] Tong, J. (1991): Disorder under heaven: Collective violence in the Ming dynasty. – Stanford: Stanford University Press 46p.
[25] Wang, Y.H. (2008): Hometown reproduction and identity divergence: Analysis of the Taiwan rebellions in the Qing dynasty. – NCHU Journal of Humanities 35p.
[26] Yang, G.Z. (2004): Economic Integration between Fujian and Taiwan in the Qing dynasty and historical turning points. – Historical Monthly (192): 58-62.
[27] Yao, Y. (2024): Dong Cha Ji Lyue Jyua. – Chinese Text Project 1p.
[28] Zhang, S.B. (2012): Political and social development in Qing Taiwan (1684-1858). – Digital Collection Room 8p.
[29] Zhang, T. (1970): The Chen Zhouquan incident from studies on rebellions in Qing Taiwan. – Taipei: Taiwan Bank Research Department Press 55p.
[30] Zheng, S.L. (2016): A study of the historical background of the migration and development of Zhangzhou people to Taiwan in the early Qing period. – Tunghai University Library Journal 8: 31-49.
[31] Zhuang, J.F. (1999): Research on the history of secret societies in Qing Taiwan. – Taipei: Nantian Press 245p.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 YU SHEN FANG
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
